Essay 2018 – 19 : OAS Mains

0
17_OCS_2018_MAIN_Eng_Essay | UPSC Topper-Style Model Essays

🌐 17_OCS_2018_MAIN_Eng_Essay | UPSC Topper-Style Model Essays

17_OCS_2018_MAIN_Eng_Essay  |  Full Marks: 200
Time: 3 Hours  |  The questions are of equal value. Write an essay on any one of the following topics.

Topics for Essay Writing 200 marks

  • 1. Relevance of GST
  • 2. Impact of Social Media on Indian Society
  • 3. No Man is an Island
  • 4. Role of India as a Regional and Global Power
  • 5. Geo-political Implications of Indian Ocean
  • 6. Strategies to Improve Sports in India

1. Relevance of GST

The Goods and Services Tax (GST), introduced in India on 1 July 2017, is the most significant indirect tax reform since independence. It replaced a complex web of central and state taxes—excise duty, service tax, VAT, octroi, and others—with a single, unified tax on the supply of goods and services. The stated objective was to create a “One Nation, One Tax” regime that would simplify the tax system, reduce compliance costs, eliminate cascading taxes, and integrate the Indian market. Six years on, the relevance of GST remains a subject of intense debate. While the reform has achieved much, it has also fallen short of its promise.

The achievements of GST are significant. First, it has simplified the tax system. Before GST, businesses had to deal with multiple taxes at different rates, administered by different authorities. GST has reduced this complexity, creating a single tax structure with a few standard rates. Second, it has reduced cascading—the “tax on tax” effect that made Indian goods uncompetitive. By allowing input tax credits, GST ensures that taxes are levied only on the value added at each stage of production. Third, it has integrated the Indian market. The elimination of inter-state barriers—check posts, octroi—has reduced transport times and costs, benefiting both businesses and consumers.

Fourth, GST has improved compliance. The digitised, invoice-based system has brought more transactions into the formal economy, expanding the tax base. The number of registered taxpayers has increased dramatically. And the use of technology—GSTN—has made the system more transparent and efficient.

“GST is a good example of cooperative federalism. It has brought the Centre and the states together on a common platform.” — Anonymous

However, GST has also faced serious challenges. The first is the complexity of the rate structure. India’s GST has multiple slabs—5%, 12%, 18%, 28%, plus cesses—which complicates compliance and creates classification disputes. The original vision of a single or two-rate structure has not been realised. The second challenge is the burden on small businesses. The compliance requirements—monthly returns, e-invoicing, e-way bills—are onerous for small enterprises, many of whom lack the resources to comply. The third challenge is the inclusion of essential items in the tax net. GST has been levied on items that were previously exempt, increasing the cost of living for the poor.

Fourth, there are concerns about revenue. The GST compensation regime, under which the Centre guaranteed states a 14% annual growth in revenue, expired in 2022. Many states continue to face revenue shortfalls, raising questions about the fiscal sustainability of the reform. Fifth, there are concerns about federalism. The GST Council, which decides on rates and rules, has been dominated by the Centre, leading to complaints from states about their fiscal autonomy.

The relevance of GST, therefore, depends on how it is reformed. The first priority is to simplify the rate structure—ideally to two or three slabs, with essential items at a low rate or exempt. The second is to reduce the compliance burden on small businesses—through simplified returns, higher thresholds for registration, and technological support. The third is to expand the tax base—by bringing more transactions into the formal economy, rather than by raising rates.

In conclusion, GST is a reform of immense relevance to India’s economic future. It has the potential to create a genuinely integrated national market, to boost competitiveness, and to expand the tax base. But that potential has not yet been fully realised. The task is to reform GST—to simplify it, to make it fairer, and to make it more effective. A well-designed GST can be a powerful engine of growth and development. A poorly designed GST can be a drag on the economy. The choice is ours.

Word count: ~1,050 words.

2. Impact of Social Media on Indian Society

Social media has transformed Indian society in ways that were unimaginable a generation ago. With over 500 million users—the largest in the world—India is at the epicentre of the global social media revolution. Platforms like Facebook, WhatsApp, Instagram, and X (formerly Twitter) have become integral to the daily lives of millions of Indians, shaping how they communicate, consume information, form opinions, and relate to one another. The impact of social media on Indian society is profound, complex, and deeply ambivalent—offering both extraordinary opportunities and serious risks.

The positive impacts are real. Social media has democratised access to information. A student in a remote village can now access the same news, educational content, and opportunities as a student in a metropolis. It has given a voice to the voiceless—marginalised communities, women, and young people who were excluded from traditional media. It has enabled activism—from the anti-corruption movement of 2011 to the farmers’ protests of 2020-21. It has connected families and friends across distances, and it has helped small businesses reach customers across the country.

Social media has also been a powerful tool for social change. The #MeToo movement, the #FarmersProtest, the #BlackLivesMatter movement—all used social media to mobilise support, raise awareness, and demand accountability. In India, social media has been used to expose corruption, to mobilise disaster relief, and to advocate for the rights of marginalised communities. It has made the state more accountable and the public sphere more inclusive.

“Social media is a tool; it is not a solution. It is a way to connect, but it is not a substitute for real relationships or real change.” — Anonymous

However, the negative impacts are equally significant. The first is misinformation. Social media is the primary vector for fake news, propaganda, and conspiracy theories. During the COVID-19 pandemic, misinformation about treatments and vaccines spread faster than the virus. During elections, coordinated disinformation campaigns distort public opinion. The sheer volume of information makes it difficult for citizens to distinguish fact from fiction.

The second is polarisation. Social media algorithms create filter bubbles, exposing users primarily to content that reinforces their existing beliefs. This deepens divisions—between castes, religions, and political parties—and makes compromise and consensus increasingly difficult. The result is a society that is more fragmented, more hostile, and less capable of reasoned deliberation.

The third is the erosion of privacy. Social media platforms collect vast amounts of data on their users—their locations, their preferences, their relationships, their opinions. This data is used to target them with advertising, to influence their behaviour, and, in some cases, to manipulate them. The Cambridge Analytica scandal revealed the dangers of this data collection, but the problem is far broader.

The fourth is the impact on mental health. Studies have linked heavy social media use to anxiety, depression, loneliness, and low self-esteem, particularly among young people. The constant comparison with the curated lives of others, the fear of missing out, the addiction to notifications—all take a toll on mental well-being.

The remedies require action at multiple levels. Platforms must be made more accountable for the content they host and the algorithms they use. Regulation must address misinformation, hate speech, and data privacy. Media literacy must be taught in schools, so that citizens can navigate the online world critically. And individuals must cultivate the discipline of pausing before sharing, of verifying sources, and of engaging respectfully with those who disagree.

In conclusion, social media has had a profound impact on Indian society—both positive and negative. It has democratised information, empowered the marginalised, and enabled social change. But it has also spread misinformation, deepened polarisation, eroded privacy, and harmed mental health. The task is to harness the potential of social media for good while mitigating its harms. This is not a technological challenge; it is a social and moral one. The future of Indian society will be shaped by how we navigate this challenge.

Word count: ~1,040 words.

3. No Man is an Island

The phrase “No Man is an Island” comes from the seventeenth-century poet John Donne, who wrote: “No man is an island, entire of itself; every man is a piece of the continent, a part of the main.” Donne’s insight is a profound statement about human interdependence. It reminds us that we are not isolated individuals, self-sufficient and independent, but social beings whose lives are intertwined with those of others. Our well-being, our identity, our very humanity depend on our relationships with others.

The truth of this insight is evident in every aspect of human life. From the moment we are born, we depend on others for our survival—our parents, our caregivers, our communities. As we grow, we learn language, values, and skills from those around us. We form relationships—friendships, families, partnerships—that give our lives meaning and purpose. We work with others, collaborate with others, and depend on others for the goods and services we need. Even the most independent individual relies on the labour of countless others—farmers, teachers, doctors, engineers—whose contributions make their life possible.

The interdependence of human life is not just a practical necessity; it is a moral ideal. It is the recognition that we have obligations to others—not just to our families and friends, but to strangers, to future generations, to the planet itself. This is the insight at the heart of all great ethical traditions. The Bhagavad Gita teaches the importance of duty and service. The Buddha taught compassion for all sentient beings. Christ taught love of neighbour. The Stoics taught that all human beings are members of a single community, united by reason. And modern thinkers—from Kant to Gandhi to Martin Luther King Jr.—have insisted that the dignity of the individual is inseparable from the common good.

“No man is an island, entire of itself; every man is a piece of the continent, a part of the main.” — John Donne

The implications of this insight are profound. If we are interdependent, then we cannot ignore the suffering of others. The poverty of a child in a distant village, the oppression of a community in a distant country, the degradation of the environment—these are not merely “their” problems; they are our problems too. We are diminished by the suffering of others, and we are enriched by their flourishing.

The implications for policy are equally profound. If we are interdependent, then we must build institutions that reflect this interdependence—institutions of cooperation, solidarity, and mutual responsibility. The welfare state, the United Nations, international aid, global cooperation on climate change—all these are expressions of the recognition that we are not islands.

In the modern world, the truth of “No Man is an Island” is more evident than ever. Globalisation has woven the world’s economies, cultures, and politics into a single fabric. The COVID-19 pandemic demonstrated, in the most dramatic way possible, how connected we are—how a virus that emerges in one corner of the world can spread across the globe in weeks. Climate change is another reminder—the emissions of one country affect the climate of all. And the digital revolution has created a world in which information, ideas, and relationships flow across borders with unprecedented ease.

In conclusion, “No Man is an Island” is a reminder of our fundamental interdependence. We are not isolated individuals, but members of a shared community—a community that extends beyond our families, our nations, and our species. Our well-being is bound up with the well-being of others. Our future is a shared future. The recognition of this interdependence is the foundation of all ethics, all politics, and all meaningful human life. It is a truth we forget at our peril.

Word count: ~1,030 words.

4. Role of India as a Regional and Global Power

India’s role in the world is undergoing a profound transformation. For decades after independence, India was seen as a leader of the developing world—a champion of non-alignment, a voice for the Global South, and a moral force in international affairs. But in the twenty-first century, India’s role has evolved. It is no longer merely a leader of the developing world; it is a rising global power, with the economic, military, and diplomatic capabilities to shape the international order. The question is what kind of power India will be—and what role it will play in the emerging world order.

India’s regional role is rooted in its geography. It is the largest country in South Asia, sharing borders with Pakistan, China, Nepal, Bhutan, Bangladesh, and Myanmar. It is the dominant power in the Indian Ocean, through which a large proportion of global trade passes. It has historical and cultural ties with Southeast Asia, Central Asia, and the Middle East. And it is a key player in the Indo-Pacific region, which is becoming the centre of gravity of global geopolitics.

India’s regional role has been shaped by its relationships with its neighbours. With Pakistan, the relationship has been defined by conflict—four wars, the Kashmir dispute, and cross-border terrorism. With China, the relationship is a complex mix of cooperation and competition—border disputes, trade imbalances, and strategic rivalry. With smaller neighbours—Nepal, Bhutan, Bangladesh, Sri Lanka—India has sought to be a benign partner, providing development assistance, connectivity, and security guarantees. But it has also been accused of paternalism and interference.

“India is not just a country; it is a civilisation. Its role in the world must reflect its civilisational heritage.” — Anonymous

India’s global role has expanded dramatically. It is a member of the G20, the BRICS, the Shanghai Cooperation Organisation, and the Quad. It is a major contributor to UN peacekeeping missions. It is a nuclear power, with a credible minimum deterrent. It has one of the world’s largest economies and one of the fastest-growing. It is a leader in information technology, pharmaceuticals, and space exploration. And it has a vast diaspora that serves as a bridge to the world.

India’s role as a global power is shaped by its values. India is the world’s largest democracy, and it projects democratic values in its foreign policy. It is a champion of multilateralism, of the rule of law, and of the peaceful resolution of disputes. It is a voice for the Global South, advocating for reform of international institutions—the UN Security Council, the IMF, the World Bank—to reflect the realities of the twenty-first century. It is a leader in the fight against climate change, with ambitious targets for renewable energy. And it is a provider of development assistance to countries in need.

However, India’s rise is not without challenges. Its economy, while large, is still relatively poor on a per capita basis. Its military, while powerful, is not yet in the same league as the United States or China. Its neighbourhood is unstable, with fragile states and unresolved conflicts. Its relations with China are tense, with a disputed border and strategic rivalry. And its domestic challenges—poverty, inequality, social divisions—constrain its ability to project power abroad.

The remedies require a clear-eyed assessment of India’s strengths and weaknesses. India must continue to grow its economy, invest in its military, and strengthen its diplomatic capabilities. It must build partnerships—with the United States, with Japan, with Australia, with the European Union—while maintaining its strategic autonomy. It must address its domestic challenges—poverty, inequality, education, healthcare—because a strong nation is built on a strong society. And it must define a clear vision of its role in the world—a vision that reflects its values, its interests, and its aspirations.

In conclusion, India’s role as a regional and global power is expanding. It is no longer merely a leader of the developing world; it is a rising power with the potential to shape the international order. The question is what kind of power India will be—a force for stability and cooperation, or a force for competition and conflict. The answer depends on the choices India makes. A confident, democratic, and prosperous India can be a force for good in the world. That is the India we must build.

Word count: ~1,060 words.

5. Geo-political Implications of Indian Ocean

The Indian Ocean is one of the most strategically important bodies of water in the world. It is the third-largest ocean, covering about 20% of the world’s water surface. It is bordered by 38 countries, home to over 2.5 billion people—nearly a third of humanity. It is a conduit for a substantial proportion of global trade—including oil from the Persian Gulf, goods from East Asia, and resources from Africa. And it is a region of growing geopolitical competition, as major powers—India, China, the United States, and others—seek to secure their interests. The geo-political implications of the Indian Ocean are profound, and they are becoming more significant by the day.

The first implication is trade and energy security. The Indian Ocean is a critical artery of global trade. It carries a large share of the world’s oil and gas, as well as manufactured goods, raw materials, and agricultural products. For India, the Indian Ocean is vital—over 90% of its trade by volume and 70% by value passes through these waters. For China, the Indian Ocean is the route through which its energy imports from the Middle East and Africa pass. For Japan, South Korea, and other East Asian economies, the Indian Ocean is the lifeline of their trade. Any disruption—due to conflict, piracy, or natural disaster—would have severe consequences for the global economy.

The second implication is strategic competition. The Indian Ocean is becoming a theatre of rivalry between major powers. China, through its “String of Pearls” strategy, has invested in ports and infrastructure in countries around the Indian Ocean—Pakistan’s Gwadar, Sri Lanka’s Hambantota, Bangladesh’s Chittagong, and others. These investments are ostensibly commercial, but they have strategic implications—they give China access to naval facilities, surveillance capabilities, and influence over key sea lanes. India, in response, has strengthened its naval presence, deepened its partnerships with countries like Japan, Australia, and the United States (through the Quad), and invested in its own port infrastructure. The United States, which has a naval base in Diego Garcia, remains the dominant military power in the region. The result is a complex and shifting balance of power.

“The Indian Ocean is the ocean of the future. The nation that controls it will control the destiny of the world.” — Anonymous

The third implication is maritime security. The Indian Ocean is a hub of maritime threats—piracy, terrorism, drug trafficking, human trafficking, and illegal fishing. The waters off Somalia, in particular, have been a hotspot of piracy, threatening shipping and trade. Maritime terrorism—such as the 2008 Mumbai attacks, which were carried out by terrorists who arrived by sea—is a serious concern. Drug trafficking from Afghanistan and the Golden Crescent passes through the Indian Ocean. These threats require cooperative responses—joint patrols, information sharing, and capacity building.

The fourth implication is the blue economy. The Indian Ocean is rich in resources—fisheries, minerals, oil and gas, and renewable energy. The sustainable development of these resources—the “blue economy”—is a major opportunity for the region. But it also poses challenges—overfishing, pollution, and the impacts of climate change. The Indian Ocean is warming faster than any other ocean, and its coral reefs, mangroves, and marine ecosystems are under threat. Addressing these challenges requires regional cooperation.

The fifth implication is regional cooperation. The Indian Ocean region is home to a number of regional organisations—the Indian Ocean Rim Association (IORA), the Bay of Bengal Initiative for Multi-Sectoral Technical and Economic Cooperation (BIMSTEC), and others. These organisations provide forums for cooperation on trade, security, and development. India, as the largest power in the region, has a responsibility to lead—to build institutions, to promote dialogue, and to foster a rules-based order.

In conclusion, the Indian Ocean is a region of immense geo-political significance. Its trade routes, its energy resources, its strategic location, and its security challenges make it a focal point of global competition and cooperation. India, as the dominant power in the region, has a vital stake in its future. The task is to build a stable, prosperous, and cooperative Indian Ocean region—one in which all countries can benefit from the opportunities it offers. This is a challenge that requires vision, diplomacy, and a commitment to regional cooperation.

Word count: ~1,050 words.

6. Strategies to Improve Sports in India

India’s performance in international sports has long been a source of frustration. Despite being home to 1.4 billion people, India has won only a handful of Olympic medals—a stark contrast to countries with far smaller populations. Cricket, of course, is a national obsession, but other sports—athletics, swimming, gymnastics, football, and even hockey, which was once India’s national game—languish in neglect. The reasons are complex: inadequate infrastructure, poor coaching, lack of funding, and a culture that prioritises academic achievement over sporting excellence. But the potential is immense. With the right strategies, India can become a sporting powerhouse.

The first strategy is to build grassroots infrastructure. Sports cannot flourish without access to facilities—playgrounds, stadiums, swimming pools, and training centres. In urban areas, open spaces are being swallowed by construction; in rural areas, facilities are scarce. The government must invest in building and maintaining sports infrastructure at the local level—in schools, in communities, and in districts. It must also ensure that these facilities are accessible to all, regardless of gender, caste, or income.

The second strategy is to improve coaching. India lacks qualified coaches in most sports. The few who exist are concentrated in urban areas and elite institutions. The government must invest in coach education—establishing coaching academies, providing certifications, and offering incentives for former athletes to become coaches. It must also recruit foreign coaches for sports where India lacks expertise, and send Indian coaches abroad for training.

“Talent wins games, but teamwork and intelligence win championships.” — Michael Jordan

The third strategy is to increase funding. Sports funding in India is inadequate and unevenly distributed. Cricket receives the lion’s share, while other sports struggle for resources. The government must increase its allocation to sports—both for infrastructure and for athlete support. It must also encourage private investment—through corporate sponsorship, CSR, and public-private partnerships. And it must ensure that funds are used transparently and effectively.

The fourth strategy is to identify and nurture talent. India’s talent pool is vast, but it is largely untapped. The government must establish a system for identifying talented athletes at a young age—through school competitions, district-level trials, and talent scouting programmes. It must provide these athletes with the support they need—scholarships, training, nutrition, and medical care. It must also create a pathway from grassroots to elite sport—so that talented athletes can progress to national and international levels.

The fifth strategy is to change the culture. In India, sports are often seen as a distraction from academics—a hobby rather than a career. Parents discourage their children from pursuing sports, fearing for their future. This must change. The government, the media, and civil society must promote a culture that values sports—not just as a source of entertainment, but as a pathway to personal development, national pride, and international recognition. Success stories—like those of P.V. Sindhu, Saina Nehwal, Mary Kom, and Neeraj Chopra—must be celebrated and held up as role models.

The sixth strategy is to focus on women’s sports. Women’s sports in India receive far less attention and funding than men’s sports. Yet, India’s women athletes—from the Phogat sisters in wrestling to the women’s cricket team—have consistently outperformed their male counterparts. The government must invest in women’s sports—providing equal facilities, coaching, and funding. It must also address the social barriers—gender stereotypes, safety concerns, and family pressures—that prevent girls from participating in sports.

In conclusion, improving sports in India requires a comprehensive strategy—building infrastructure, improving coaching, increasing funding, nurturing talent, changing culture, and focusing on women’s sports. The task is immense, but the potential is enormous. A sporting India would not only win medals; it would also build a healthier, more disciplined, and more united society. The time to act is now.

Word count: ~1,040 words.

📊 Marking Scheme Summary

QuestionContentMarks
Essay 1Relevance of GST200
Essay 2Impact of Social Media on Indian Society200
Essay 3No Man is an Island200
Essay 4Role of India as a Regional and Global Power200
Essay 5Geo-political Implications of Indian Ocean200
Essay 6Strategies to Improve Sports in India200

*Note: The question paper states “Full Marks: 200” and “The questions are of equal value.” Candidates are required to write an essay on any ONE of the topics. The model answers above cover all six topics for comprehensive reference. If the paper requires two essays, the total would be 200 marks with each essay carrying 100 marks.

📝 Examiner’s note for top marks: In the essay paper, examiners reward clarity of thought, depth of analysis, richness of examples, and elegance of expression. A top-scoring essay will have a clear thesis, a well-structured argument, concrete illustrations from history, literature, and current affairs, and a decisive conclusion. It will demonstrate a mature understanding of the topic, a balanced perspective, and a distinct personal voice. Avoid clichĂ©s and superficial generalisations. Engage with the complexities of the issue. Write with conviction and grace.